I was recently asked to debate the following topic: “When it comes to using social media effectively, once again B2B marketers are behind their B2C counterparts” and take the opposing side with Steve Kemish. I’m fortunate enough to have worked both in the B2C and the B2B arena so I can easily see the plus points for both sides of this debate. My first initial thought on the subject was that B2C has so many well know case studies, which are often bounded about at conferences and events, so I had an idea what Debbie Williams and Mark Mason would be talking about to put their “for the motion” argument across.
Undeterred and rather competitive I set out to research and use some of my own B2B social media experience to investigate and document some world firsts in social media from the B2B community. My aim was to discredit the statement that B2B is always following B2C. On reflection, it wasn’t that difficult. After all, I had 2 world firsts of my own and so was confident. But rather than this being about work which I had done though. I wanted to add some other examples. These were:
So, with all my research and preparation in hand, I awaited the social media debate with much anticipation, secure in the knowledge that I would probably lose the debate since most people would already be familar with the B2C examples and may have actually used some of the applications, environments or games created.
First up was Mark, who eloquently spoke about the how B2Cs were way ahead of the B2B community and in fact were much more effective. He also pointed out that B2B brands often lagged behind their B2C counterparts, as they were slow to take up opportunities. In particular he noted that Twitter was not being used as a thought leadership piece by B2Bs. He also highlighted that some B2B brands had fallen short on some rather bad experiences with corporate blogging. My thought on this was that it really doesn’t stop you in your tracks when considering social media.

Second up was Steve, with some rather bold statements to the audience, suggesting that they make up their own minds from the examples he would now demonstrate. He illustrated with a great example on VMware, where product demonstrations and how to guides are all recorded on video and hosted on YouTube (the world’s second largest search engine). He also argued that social media for B2Bs was largely about targeting and finding out where your customers are. B2C knows where people are but not who they are, it really is more about mass marketing for B2Cs in social media. B2B is more targeted and therefore can be more effective. Steve nicley countered Mark’s statements.

After Steve’s feisty argument, Debbie was next up. Her opening statement was impressive, withover 320 B2C brands active on social media. She spoke about many of the well known B2C social media examples; Absolute Vodka, Avon, Coca Cola, Harley Davidson, Ford and Blend it. All valid examples, but nothing outstanding an no world firsts discussed. From her speech I concluded that most consumers using social media are Avon ladies riding Harley Davidson motorbikes and sometimes driving Ford Fiestas, blending and drinking lots of Black Russian cocktails!

By now I was a little nervous, being the last person to speak and having to summarise my fellow debating speakers’ points. Well, I presented my four B2B cases all being world firsts, as detailed above. In my summary I concluded that B2B Innovation = ideas + innovation + risk and that we, as B2B marketers are truly only limited by our own imagination.

What followed was an interactive question and thought sharing session, ending with Steve and I winning the debate. I guess the audience appreciated our side of the argument, but I also I think presenting and highlighting some of the world firsts in social media also helped win the day for our side (Team: Little & Large).

The debate was hosted by ABBA (Association of Business to Business Agencies) and held at RSA, London, a lovely building with a treasure cove of vaults below the main building where drinks and canapés were served after the debate, kindly sponsored by Equifax. Photographs were taken by John Wilkinson.